Creative Errors

One day a weaver, distracted by sorrow over the death of her child, unknowingly let the shuttle slip, leaving a slight aberration in the cloth. Later a foreman inspecting the cloth saw this tiny flaw in the weave. He took a photograph, blew it up, and made a flag that aggrandized the flaw. Every day, he walked past the weaver waving this flag and taunting her. After a while the weaver left his shop. She found a new place of work with a woman overseer.

Days and weeks and months and then years rolled by until her sorrow no longer overwhelmed her. But she had not forgotten why she left the former shop. How could she forget? The flag with her aggrandized error was emblazoned in her memory.

One day she went to the overseer and said, “I know a way that we could put a sort of pattern in the cloth we weave that would make our product quite distinctive.” She demonstrated how by dropping the shuttle ever twenty threads, the cloth took on a sort of glow from the repeated ‘flaws’ made by the weaver. The woman overseer was thrilled with the sample she was shown and asked the weaver to train all the weavers so they could make this very distinctive cloth. Over time the material woven in that shop became prized for its unusual luster.

Meanwhile the originally flawed cloth made its way into the world and a dressmaker bought it. When she examined the cloth, she found the flaw. This did not bother her for she was a very good dressmaker and she saw immediately that she could make of it a pleated skirt that would hide the flaw beneath a fold of cloth. The whole piece of material was truly beautiful and she was proud of the skirt she made.

The pleated skirt was purchased by a woman in midlife who had some knowledge both of weaving and of the ups and downs of life. One day as her hands smoothed the beautiful cloth a finger felt the tiny flaw. She smiled and began to sing. “Now I know the weaver who made this cloth! Like me, she has known sorrow and how it seeps into one’s soul. From now on, whenever I feel this tiny alteration in the cloth, I will celebrate this woman whose life I share.”

Years passed and the owner of the pleated skirt died. Her family came and in sorrow packed away her clothes and took them to a resale store. One day an artist entered the shop, looking for something interesting. She found the pleated skirt because the beauty of the material caught her eye. Examining the skirt, her gaze fell upon a shiny place hidden beneath a fold. Indeed, the former owner had rubbed the ‘flaw’ so often during her long life that the texture of the cloth had softened in that particular spot.

As she paid for the skirt, a smile came to the artist’s face. She whispered to herself. “Ah, the shiny area is the bindu. This is the tiny place from which my new creation will be made. This will be the center of a massive flower whose beauty will rock the viewer. Starting from the shiny spot, the folds and creases I make in this extraordinary cloth will catch the light in special ways. How lucky I am to have found this amazing cloth. I wonder who the weaver was. She must have been a sensitive woman to have woven such exquisite material.”

Travel and textile book by Karen Beck and Joshua Hirschstein.

Playing in Northern Spain

Using materials I collected in our travels, I made this accordion collage
to capture some of the playful and delightful moments that Karen and I shared.

Outside the Guggenheim, Jeff Koons' Puppy
and Tulips are inviting sculptures and the surrounding
older architecture is charming.

Inside the Guggenheim, Richard Serra's iron sculptures
create a monumental labyrinth that covers the first floor.

Burgos is a livable city full of surprises such as the Book Museum,
the riverside promenade, outdoor restaurants, and the cathedral.

The beauty of the Bay of Biscay is
matched with excellent cuisine.

In Bilbao we used the tram system that follows the river
and takes you from Old Town to all sorts of interesting places.

The Bertiz Cafe was our Bilbao hangout. I've made
the flyer into a pocket to hold maps and our trip agenda.

Day or night, Frank Gehry's architecture
is one of the wonders of the world.

Since Europeans no longer use their medieval churches
they have figured out how to make them into spectacular museums.

The Basque Museum in Bilbao features both
pre-Christian symbols and a former monastery.

The Belles Artes Museum in Bilbao is a great
place to see contemporary Spanish art.

Because of the former importance of the cathedral of
Burgos, the Burgos Museum holds beautiful medieval art.

I have dedicated this image from the Bosque Museum in Bilbao
to Angeles Arrien who was proud of her Bosque sheep herding heritage.

Some of the materials we collected were too beautiful to cut up
so I glued them to the back side of my Spanish collage.

Ancient Relatives in Northern Spain

Book Museum in Burgos, Castile and Leon, Spain.
Our travels in Northern Spain took us beyond the world of books.

When Karen Snyder invited me to join her in an exploration of Spain, I suggested the northern region because I had longed to see the cave art at Altamira. I saw this as an opportunity to visit my ancient paternal ancestors. The path out of Africa taken by my paternal ancestors was east across the south end of the Red Sea into the Arabian peninsula, north into the Ancient Near East, and then west along the northern edge of the Mediterranean Sea to the Iberian peninsula where they hung out during one of the recurring ice ages. In 2014 I had learned during a visit to Etruscan ruins in Tuscany that my ancestors were an earthy people. I was eager to see who they were by the time they had reached Spain. 

Karen and me on site at the archeological digs on the Sierra of Atapuerca.

There are some thoughts and feelings that one can only have in situ. All the books and photographs perused before a journey set you up but it is not until you are on site that random thoughts and ideas begin to coalesce into bigger ideas and possible insights. I arrived at some hypotheses during our visits to the Altamira Museum outside the medieval village of Santillana del Mar, the Museum of Human Evolution in Burgos, and the archeological digs in the Sierra de Atapuerca. Books we collected on site also pushed my thinking.

Altamira Cave - large Bison

Altamira Museum - Who Are We?

My first hypothesis occurred in the replica cave of the Altamira Museum. I was most impacted by the ceiling paintings in the Polychrome Chamber. The animals painted there were not the ones Homo sapiens hunted. The time during which these paintings were made was the beginning of the Holocene. During the warming of the climate then Bison and Roe Deer were leaving northern Spain and going further north where it was colder. Homo sapiens on the other hand preferred the warmer weather and, having domesticated some animals, were moving toward a more sedentary lifestyle. I believe the cave art at Altamira represents the awareness of Homo sapiens that something of significance was occurring. Whether they wished to commune with the bison and deer to better understand what was occurring or wanted to use this art to help fellow homo sapiens understand the changes occurring, this art dramatizes the end of an era.

Altamira Cave - Large hind / Roe Deer 

Viewers of cave art are often puzzled by the many depictions of human hands. My second hypothesis involving this repeated painting of human hands came to me later at the Human Evolution Museum in Burgos. There I saw a presentation on the difference between the hands of chimpanzees, a common primate ancestor with hominids, and Homo Sapiens. The grip in Chimps is in their four fingers because their thumb is directly opposite those fingers. When our ancestors left the trees and began walking on the earth, the thumb evolved to be closer to the index finger, allowing for a grip between the thumb and index finger. This allowed for greater precision in the making of tools. Their better technology gave Homo Sapiens an advantage over other animal species. 

Thumb and index finger brought increased dexterity.

In upper left corner - Handprint  - Altamira Cave

Our hominid ancestors were masters of observation. It seems to me that cave artists who painted hands were at some level attempting to say, “This is what makes us different than other animals. We do not have hooves or paws. Our hands are what has given us our refined technology and hold a key to our future.” Perhaps, as some have suggested, the hands were an expression of “I was here; we were here."Or "I am the one (we are the ones) who made this picture”. But even if that is the case, it seems to me to be significant that these artists would choose as a symbol of human presence precisely the characteristic that distinguished them from other animals.

Atepuerca - How Did We Become Human?

Located not far from a UNESCO heritage site cathedral, the museum is a
modern architectural counterpart to the tall spires of the Gothic cathedral.

An enormous chart on the back of a wall divider gave a small sense
of the huge expanse of time during which evolution led to Homo sapiens.

From the province of Cantabria, we traveled three hours by bus southeast to Burgos in the province of Castile & Leon. Ongoing excavations over the past fifty years at the Sierra de Atapuerca outside the city of Burgos have produced 83% of all bones showing the evolution of hominids into Homo sapiens. With the construction of the Museo de la Evolution Humana, Burgos became the world capital for human evolution. Adjacent buildings allow for ongoing conferences and dialogues about the evolving knowledge base on evolution. There will be more finds made in other parts of the world that will alter and refine the current story of evolution, but for now the museum in Burgos is the keeper of the human story.

Basic structure of the brain.

I arrived at a third hypothesis after viewing depictions of and text on the human brain at the Human Evolution Museum.  These experiences gave me a different understanding of what may have occurred between Neanderthals and Homo Sapiens. Since most of the nutrients we ingest go to feed the brain, the difference in body size between these two hominids could have made a big difference.  Hominids left Africa much earlier than Homo Sapiens and evolved into Neanderthals. In order to exist in the colder climate of northern Eurasia, these hominids developed a larger body frame that would have required more nutrients than the smaller hominids who remained in the warmer climate of Africa. Thus, more of the nutrients absorbed by those remaining in Africa could go toward the development of the brain. Although the size of the two brains was about the same, that of Homo Sapiens evidently became more complex.

Who Will We Become?

Constants of human evolution: climate and ecological changes, biological responses,
cultural responses (technological development), migration to new habitats,
cultural + biological integration processes, and socialization of innovations.

Another factor in the question of why Homo Sapiens had replaced Neanderthals in Eurasia within a period of 12,000 years could have been the population advantage that Homo Sapiens had over Neanderthals. Our hominid ancestors could have only one child at a time and that child had to be nurtured by its mother from birth to maturity. Within Homo Sapiens, living in the warmer climate of Africa, a pattern of maturation within community (childhood) developed. After birthing a child, the mother needed to nurture it for a shorter time period before it could continue developing by learning from other community members, allowing her to have another child. As Homo Sapiens expanded in population their species size outstripped that of Neanderthals.

Today, however, what was once an advantage has become a threat to both Homo Sapiens and planet earth. Our accelerated population growth is outstripping the resources needed to sustain people on Mother Earth. What responses will we make?

Sign for Camino (Santiago de Compostela) in village of Atepuerca.
The human footprint on planet earth has been enormous.

Art Changes Everything

Northern Spain offered a rich cultural experience.

Symbol Is Key

When the Guggenheim Museum opened in 1997, Bilbao was
struggling to recover from the collapse of industry.

The same area twenty years later.

Guggenheim Museum in Bilbao, Basque Country,  recently celebrated it’s 20^th anniversary. In looking over what has happened in Bilbao since its opening in 1997, it is clear that Frank Gehry’s stupendous architectural construction altered the landscape of the city. It both symbolized the ship building and industrial past of Bilbao and launched its future as a cultural center for Europe. 

Bilbao’s depressed shipping port area has been totally transformed as a result of shifting the city’s economic base to include culture and a service sector as well as traditional industry.

A Changing Story of Meaning

This image of Africa as a human skull greeted us at the entrance to the
Altamira Museum. More and more research is showing that Homo Sapiens
came into existence throughout the African continent. 

Entering the replica cave at Altamira in Cantabria is
an awe inspiring experience.  

To get to the Altamira caves, a cave replica, and a state of the art museum, it is helpful to go to the charming Medieval town of Santillana del Mar. It is impossible to overstate the impact made by the paintings discovered in the caves of Altamira, as well as in the caves of Lascaux in France, near the end of the 19^th century. 

While most people had previously assumed that Western culture began in Greece and/or with the spread of Christianity through the Roman Empire, the power and creative techniques discovered at Altamira reveal that Homo Sapiens of the Paleolithic era experienced and represented their encounter with the transcendent. The artists of Altamira and stone artists in every part of the world paved the way for further abstract thinking and the development of written language.

Archeology as Rituals of Discovery

The patient work at Atapuerca by hundreds of archeologists
and students over the last sixty years has resulted in
a new story about our human evolution.

Part of our tour of archeological sites in Atapuerca included
demonstrations of techniques used by our Paleolithic ancestors, such
as their color formulations and airbrushing techniques.

Construction of a railroad for transporting iron ore in the 1960’s uncovered the first discovery of hominid bones in the region of Atapeurca, an area ten miles outside of the city of Burgos in Castile and Leon. Since that time archeologists have been faithfully digging in a number of limestone karst areas. Following precise scientific practices they have uncovered 83% of all hominid bones so far discovered in the world. Their bone and artifact findings have provided evidence of homo evolution right up to Neanderthals. 

The world began to take notice in the 1990’s and the city of Burgos created a Museum of Human Evolution to help people understand human evolution in relation to a changing planet. From the front of the museum one can see the spires of the cathedral of Burgos, a world heritage site, reminding visitors that experiencing the transcendent takes different forms in different epochs.

In the coming weeks I hope to continue sharing more about how Art Changes Everything.